297 Wantagh Ave, Levittown, NY 11756 (Closed on Monday)
Our delicious take on the classic black and white cookie - a marble pound cake iced with the same chocolate and vanilla fondant icing.
We create customized cakes, cupcakes, cake pops and cookies for all your special events and can make your vision a reality. Check out our Gallery Page for more photos. For quotes on any custom order, call or visit the bakery or go to our Custom Orders page.
Sweet Surrender Bake House offers high end quality baked goods such as Breads, Donuts, Pies, Cakes, Pastries, Cupcakes, Cookies - all at sensible prices. All items are freshly made on premises from our classic Jelly Donuts to our Signature Specialty pastry - the Crannoli™ (a donut/croissant/cannoli in one). We also offer decorative Custom Cakes and Favors for any occasion. Just one trip will have you coming back again and again for our delicious takes on classic recipes. Our philosophy is simple - use only the finest ingredients to make exceptional breads and desserts! Everything is baked to perfection and filled with inspiration!
Cousins Tanya Salagiannis and Helen Kyrillidis opened up Sweet Surrender Bake House in September of 2012, purchasing the former New Levittown Park Bake Shop on Wantagh Avenue in Levittown. After making some tweaks to existing recipes, introducing more modern pastries and making major renovations to both the exterior and interior, Sweet Surrender Bake House improved upon the Bake Shop’s stellar reputation for quality baked goods and is proud of its high marks. Sweet Surrender Bake House has been featured on Fox 5’s Good Day New York, where the anchors, Greg Kelly and Rosanna Scotto, were blown away by all the delicious baked treats especially the Crannoli, the rainbow cookies and the black and white cookies. Sweet Surrender has also been featured in Newsday, the Levittown Tribune and various different food blogs and reviews. Owner Tanya Salagiannis has even competed on a the Food Network show Rewrapped. They have participated in CP Nassau's Taste and Toast the Town, where their sweets won Best Dessert in 2014, 2015 and 2016 and their showpiece (made up entirely of bread) helped them win Best Overall Table in 2016. They also give back to the local community as much as possible which is why they have been awarded appreciation awards from the local Levittown Knights of Columbus, Forgotten Friends of Long Island and the Testaverde Foundation.